Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh.
And Salam Sejahtera.
Alhamdulillahi rabbil alameen, wa bihi nastaeen. Wa laa akibatuhu lil muttaqeen, wa laa unduhana illa allath zalimeen. Ash hadu an la ilaha illallah, wa laa dawla syariqa lah. Wa ash hadu anna sayyidina Muhammadin abduhu wa rasuluh.
Terima kasih kepada pengacara majlis yang dihormati kepada semua rakan-rakan Menteri Besar yang bersama dengan saya pada hari ini, distinguished guests, our delegates, ladies and gentlemen.
Today is a very beautiful occasion. We are here in this beautiful building. And I've seen a good number of familiar faces today from his excellencies, high commissioners and ambassadors, representatives from EU, industrial players in various sectors, corporate people, friends from universities, our member of parliament, the assemblymen, the political leaders, and so on and so forth.
When we discuss economic development, we often begin with growth figures, investment commitments and export performance. True enough, these indicators matter. At least for now, the numbers become part and parcel of our everyday report of economic activities, be it the numbers of inflation, GDP, money comes in and money goes out.
And for decades, we have measured success by growth, investment and exports. I think it's something that we have to agree on from now, that the numbers itself is trivial and insignificant to ordinary people on the street.
If we look at and read carefully what has been written by a couple numbers of Nobel laureates in economic sciences, for example, Abhijit Banerjee, the recipient of the 2019 Nobel in economy, he directly notes that rising GDP numbers do not automatically improve the living conditions, in which he argued that the metrics like stable employment, healthcare access, education quality and wealth distribution are the only true markers of public welfare.
Another Nobel laureate, I think you are quite well known, Stiglitz, the recipient of 2001, frequently highlighted that how the growth number championed by global financial entities like the World Bank often comes at the expense of emerging markets and working class.
He critiques conventional models that mask growing inequality behind positive top-line growth statistics. Because people do not live in GDP, real people like us, especially the people on the street, they live in rent, in food prices, in transportation costs, they are dealing with school fees and the hope of jobs.
A young graduate without work does not feel a growth rate. It doesn't mean anything to them, it's just trivial numbers. A family whose wages are outrun by prices does not feel an investment figure. We can talk about trillions or billions of investment figures, but their daily activities are outrun by cost of living.
When people see wealth rising at the top while their own prospects stand still, and worse, regressing, and when they feel that no one is listening, then anger finds the streets. This is probably what happened in a number of European countries at the moment, even though we have a different explanation to that. Probably some part of it is a bigger agenda by certain people to incite some instability in that region.
Of course, for every argument on one side, there is always another argument on the other side of the table, just like the two sides of every coin. Amazingly, if you look carefully at what happened in the surroundings, everybody believes that the world is in its shape, it's a sphere, but the community that believes that the world is flat is having their traction and supporters. So there are always two sides of every argument.
But while Stiglitz and the other Nobel laureates explain how the numbers are set, whether GDP or inflation, or money comes in and money goes out, it's not as important as other variables, the other powerful school of thought argues that GDP growth remains the single most important metric for improving the lives of ordinary people. So these economists, often leaning towards free market capitalism, supply economics, or growth-centric development, argue that focusing on wealth redistribution or alternative metric matters, like if the economic pie isn't growing.
Ladies and gentlemen, nearly a month ago, I was having a tea and some serious discussion with His Excellency, British High Commissioner, on my obsession with science and mathematics. We talked about large neutron colliders, which is not part of the interest of today's gathering, and prime number theory, particularly the living legend of Sir Roger Penrose, the Nobel winner in physics in 2020, and of course the remarkable story of Indian mathematician Sri V. Nassar Ramanujan on prime numbers in the last century.
Similarly, the topic of prime numbers means nothing, or just trivial numbers to the ordinary people. Little did we know that both prime number theory and mathematical asymmetry is one of the backbones in our economy, particularly they directly protect our money, secure our data, and enable global digital trade.
Without the understanding of prime numbers, e-commerce, digital banking, credit card processing, and global wire transfer would be unsafe for hackers. I'm not standing here to talk about any of those number theories, otherwise our session today is going to be a very boring session, but rather to give us some sense that we need to work harder, with some political will, if we want to explore any other metrics that would be able to describe and portray or characterize or illustrate more realistic economy and the interconnectivity with the well-being of our people.
Some are already trying with all sorts of indexes, such as number one, multidimensional poverty index, human development index, OECD better life index, and happiness index, which I strongly believe that all are splendid, but we need more other key variables and factoring to give more consideration to cater for different domestic economy, geographical, cultural, and religious beliefs as well.
Ladies and gentlemen, as policy makers, we must ask what those numbers mean for the people who live that we are entrusted to improve. Are families earning better incomes? Are young people finding meaningful work? Are local businesses becoming more productive and competitive? And are we building an economy that the next generation can depend on? Are we building an economy of the country or somebody else's economy?
These questions are central to the future of SG4, comprising, as we all know, Selanganu, Kelantan, Kedah, and Perlis. They are also relevant to Malaysia as a whole.
Across our four states, we have natural resources, agriculture land, industrial capabilities, tourism assets, and strategic connections to regional markets, and this has been explained by Dr. Hilman. Yet economic potential does not automatically translate into prosperity. Resources can be accepted in one state while most of the value is created elsewhere.
An investment can bring impressive figures without building strong local suppliers. An industry can expand while local workers remain in low-paying jobs. This is why our task must go beyond attracting investment.
We must strengthen our ability to turn resources into productive industries, develop local capabilities that is more value-created benefits to our people. I think in general, you might want to say that, okay, we try our best to get to the state and try to propose, to give our proposal to any business and any project. And I knew your frustrations at times, or even many times, dealing with the states, at the state levels, local authorities, and government agencies, be it at the state level or at the federal level.
In reality, we are on the same boat. Issues of late approval by local authorities and the issues of environmental agencies, processes, and so on. And even some would complain that sometimes the government agencies or the leaders of the government agencies contemplating at times at the state level decision-making process.
To tell you the truth, any kind of weaknesses on our side, of course, that's our bad. I would not even try to defend this kind of weaknesses. However, I would like to summarize that we are tremendously facing all sorts of things.
Number one, for example, I would say out of 10 investment proposals that we have received, probably 7 out of 10 is either lousy proposal, lousy introducer or broker. And sometimes it's a scam all along. And sometimes they propose the things, but the objective is another. And sometimes just a piece of paper without sounding fun in place. They just want to get approval, and with that letter of approval, they go to the bank and try to find funding. And that puts us into dilemma. So that's where comes the stringent part of the state government processing center, that we have to be more stringent.
Number two, the problem with the previous or the past problem that we have, submission without fully supporting documents, not enough evidence, and so on and so forth. They have applied, they have filled up the papers, they have filled up the form, or even filled up the online form, but without proper documentation. And that, we cannot make any decision.
Number three, for an ongoing project, for example, failed to execute and failed to complete due to various reasons. And with the high cost of construction materials and so on and so forth, raw materials, and that becomes worse.
And this is all that makes any state government and local authorities becoming more stringent in the selection process. And of course, number four, we cannot deny that there are also some competing and conflicting authorities between state and federal agencies. And I think this is one of the things that when we come into power at the federal level, we are going to try the best way how to solve this competing and conflicting power between the state and the federal.
Today, I would like to share how SG4 could contribute to that effort within a fairer and more capable Malaysian economy. Now we talk about Malaysia in general. Ladies and gentlemen, in my recent parliamentary debate on Supply Bill 2027, I emphasized two principles, which is fairness and capacity.
Fairness means every citizen and every state should have a meaningful opportunity to benefit from national development, regardless of where they live. Capacity means having the institution's skills, infrastructure, and financial resources to turn those opportunities into results. We need both. We need fairness and we need capacity. Fairness is the foundation of the economy that we want to build. By fairness, I mean three things.
Number one, fair to every community. Malaysia's strength is its diversity. We have Malays, Chinese, Indians, and people of Sabah and Sarawak, the orang asli and every other community. Fairness does not mean taking from one to give to another. It means growing the economy so that every community has a place in it and giving those priorities to those in need, wherever they live and wherever their background.
Number two, fair to every region. Where you are born must not decide how far you can go. The East Coast, the Northern and the Kelang Valley, Johor, Sabah and Sarawak, all contribute to this nation and all must share in its progress. Sabah and Sarawak must have their rights under the Malaysia Agreement 63 honoured and their aspirations respected.
Number three, we need to be fair to every generation, in which we must not borrow from our children's future and we must not leave them in an economy that offers talent but no reward at home. If we address one without the other, development gaps will remain. So the three important attributes or components need to stay together if we want to have a better economy and more fairness in our country.
On that basis, I believe we should consider a renewed Malaysia economic model, or MEM, I would say, with the well-being of our people as its central purpose.
This should build on strengths of existing national policies. We have a beautiful, big volume of national policies from various ministries. We can live with that, but at the same time we can come to more serious improvement and address the structural gaps that continue to hold back regions and communities.
The practical question is how to make economic progress more productive, more widely shared and more sustainable, and whether development gaps between regions are narrowing. That requires high-value industries, stronger domestic enterprises and the effective use of technology.
It also requires development strategies that recognize the different strengths and needs of each region. Good governance is essential, of course, to this effort. Public resources must be managed responsibly. Investment decisions must withstand scrutiny and institutions must be capable of delivering what they have planned. The aim is an economy that can withstand uncertainty while giving more Malaysians the opportunity to improve their lives.
This is consistent with Makasih Syariah, protecting life, faith, intellect, family and wealth. In economic policy, this principle reminds us of our responsibility to safeguard human dignity, uphold trust and consider the welfare of our future generations. The benefits of development must reach Malaysians of every community.
SG4 can provide a practical platform for advancing this approach through cooperation among our four states. Each SG4 state brings different strengths. Our task is to understand how those strengths can complement one another. Tengganu has established capabilities in petroleum and gas, petrochemical, heavy industries, maritime industries and tourism.
Kelantan, on the other hand, offers opportunities in agro-industry, halal industries, heritage, tourism and cross-border trade. Kedah has strength in high-tech manufacturing, semiconductors, agriculture and logistics. Perlis occupies a strategic position for border trade, renewable energy, agro-industry and economic activities connecting Malaysia with southern Thailand.
We should develop these strengths with a clearer view of the opportunities across state boundaries. Investors look at the reliability of the supply chain, access to markets, the availability of skills and the cost of doing business, and ease of doing business as well. Our cooperation must address this practical consideration.
This is the basis of SG4's integrated economic corridor within our limited framework. Of course, we are still bound by our federal constitution, the power of the state, the jurisdiction of the state and the federal, and the division between those two. It would connect the industrial development with energy, logistics, technology and workforce preparation across the four states.
The value of cooperation lies in making this connection work for businesses and communities on the ground. The purpose will be practical coordination, identifying opportunities, resolving implementation barriers, and helping local firms to participate in regional supply chains.
Ladies and gentlemen, the industrial transformation also requires access to capital. A promising project will remain a proposal if its financing structure is weak or its risks are poorly understood. We therefore need to give the financing question the same attention as the industrial question.
Our natural resources, industrial lands, location and workforce provide a good starting point. To develop them responsibly, we need credible projects, capable institutions and investors with a long-term perspective. This is why we could possibly explore the development of an SG4 Islamic financial hub. Its purpose would be to connect Sharia-compliant capital with productive investment across our four states.
Malaysia's experience in Islamic banking, sukuk, takaful and Sharia-compliant investment provides a foundation on which to build. We should examine how the national expertise can support regional industrial development and improve access to financing for domestic enterprises.
The International Financial Centre offers useful lessons in attracting capital, developing expertise and building investor confidence. For SG4, the appropriate approach is to define a focus role that complements Malaysia's existing financial ecosystem. The role should be grounded in the financing needs of the real economy.
Sectors like energy, infrastructure, manufacturing, technology and trade could provide the initial areas of focus. Renewable energy projects, for example, could be assessed for green sukuk and suitable Islamic financing instruments. Infrastructure and logistics could attract long-term investment partners, subject to sound project economics.
Technology companies could benefit from investment funds suited to their stage of development. Micro, small and medium enterprises would need accessible trade finance, supply chain finance and appropriate Islamic financial technology solutions.
Ladies and gentlemen, on the issue of green energy, the strategy industries and regional connectivity, we are already embarking on this Green Energy Initiative. The global economy is undergoing major transformations, driven by technological advancement, energy transition and changes in international supply chains.
SG4 must therefore position itself to participate meaningfully in this development. One area worth examining is an SG4 green and clean energy industrial hub, built around complementary capabilities for our four states.
Over time, we could access opportunities to renewable electricity in higher-value activities, including green hydrogen and green ammonia, where technology, infrastructure and market conditions make them viable.
We must balance energy security, affordability, industrial competitiveness and environmental sustainability. Strategic minerals, including rare earth elements, the most sought-after elements now by many countries, also warrant careful assessment. With approximately 70% of the country's REE resources, the rare earth element seated in four states, 70%, according to the latest data by GMG, the region has considerable potential to attract investment and develop high-value industries.
The objective should not be limited to extracting and exporting raw materials. That's not our number one target. Where resources are commercially viable, we should examine processing, advanced materials, technology transfer and downstream manufacturing, and participation by local partners.
Decisions must be supported by scientific evidence, clear regulations and rigorous environmental safeguards, including the protection of water resources and surrounding communities. The objective is to develop industrial capabilities, not just merely extracting raw materials and sending them out, while meeting our responsibility to the people and, most importantly, to our environment.
Equally important in this part is the development of efficient logistic infrastructure. For the East Coast, the East Coast Maritime and Logistic Gateway could be explored to connect port facilities, industrial areas and transport networks more effectively. This means that we need to explore how Kuantan Port facilities in Kemaman and the East Coast Railing could support an integrated network.
At the same time, we must not overlook tourism, agro-industry and community-based economic development. We need better market access and business support, which could help tourism enterprises, cooperatives, farmers and fishing communities to capture more value, not just bystanders looking at whatever development is going on.
Ladies and gentlemen, on the other part, I would like to stress on the strengthening economic federalism. All these opportunities bring us to a very fundamental question. Do states have the capacity and the institutional space to develop their economic strength effectively? It's a very big question to answer today. And within the Malaysian federal structure, cooperation between the federal government and state government remains, number one, very essential and tremendously important. We cannot deny that.
Economic federalism should help both levels of government work together more effectively, with clear responsibilities and fair opportunities for development. A Malaysia that is fair to every region is a stronger Malaysia.
Fairness involves the allocation of national resources. It also involves the conditions that allow states to develop their own capabilities. In the parliamentary debate on Budget 2037, as I said much earlier, I proposed an interstate fiscal and development equalization formula. It's a new concept to understand.
But we need to understand that whatever the concept that we have, the formula that we are having now under the current structures was made based on the very beginning of our country in 1957, in which we have the power of the federal. We have in our constitution the shared power between state and federal, state power, jurisdiction, and all that. And the basis of that structure was made in 1957.
Fast forward many, many years, we need a different formula. As we can see in some other parts of the world, they already developed quite a tremendous formula, like what happened in Australia, in Germany, in Canada.
The intentions of our suggestion of interstate fiscal and development equalization formula is to make development allocations more transparent, consistent and responsive to actual needs, and above all, away from political sentiment. And sometimes it becomes carrot and stick by the federal government to the state government. And I wish we could change that after GE16, inshallah. The aim is to strengthen cooperation within our federalism.
It's not the purpose of we have this kind of formula to make the state work by themselves alone, but we continue with the same setup. We work together within a state setup, and we work together with the federal government. A major framework should enable states to contribute more effectively while supporting national energy security and economic development.
When federal fiscal resources are constrained, as it is now, or to make matters worse, skewed to a political weightage, or the politics become one of the thick criteria in your consideration, how we would be able to strengthen the state to develop more productively and to have more productive activities and contribute more to national growth is the big question we are posing now.
So giving proper attention to that question could benefit the Federation as a whole. The very reason we want to change that setup that has been in place since 1957 is because we want to assist federal as well. It would be a no-brainer to debate that a stronger state economy can contribute to build a stronger Malaysia. That's the fact that we cannot deny.
Ladies and gentlemen, on my final notes, I wish to emphasize that our responsibility is to improve the lives of the people that we serve.
For young graduates, that may mean a meaningful career closer to home. For small businesses and enterprises, it means the opportunity to become a reliable supplier to a larger industry. For a farmer or fishing family, it may mean better access to markets and more dependable income and disposable income.
These are the outcomes that give economy policy its meaning. We want our young people to have the skills and opportunities to build their future in SG4 while remaining free to pursue opportunities wherever they choose. We want local enterprises to grow in capability and compete in national and international supply chains.
And we want rural communities to see a clear place for themselves in the economy we are developing. The other day when I was meeting with a number of EU diplomats, they asked very specific questions on considering after GE16, for example, because now EU with Malaysia, we are on the negotiation of the Treaty Agreement, so they want our views, what happened after GE16, should we have a different setup of the government taking place.
I said, of course we want to work together, and we want to have a mutual benefit for both parties, not just the EU companies, but for Malaysia as well, and the local enterprises and local businesses, so that they can prosper as well and they can compete at a global scale. There's no point to have any kind of agreement for that matter, but we are going to neglect the local enterprises and local businesses in that new setup.
And also we want rural communities to see a clear place for themselves in the economy that we are developing. This goes back to the original point that I mentioned this morning, that the numbers may be rosy and paint very nice pictures on the investment, on the inflation, on the GDP, but at the end of the day, the normal people, the normal enterprises, the small-scale industries, for example, if they are not going to benefit in these big numbers, it becomes trivial and meaningless to them.
Our policies must be judged by how effectively we make those opportunities possible. That is the practical meaning of fair and thriving economic development. SG4 can contribute by developing its own capabilities and connecting them more effectively with the national economy.
Our cooperation can create additional value for Malaysia. We are not going to compete with anybody or any state. When our enterprise grows, our workers become more skilled, and our industries become more productive, the benefits can extend beyond our state boundaries.
Let us take this proposal forward through very serious study, constructive dialogue and practical cooperation. I know in a kind of convention like this, we are not going to solve the world's problem in a day. Similarly, this room is not built by one day.
So we need connection, we need early set-up, and understanding that we want to work together, and let's continue with the discussion, and hopefully we can find a win-win solution for the mutual benefits of our states, our local enterprises, and the bigger enterprises.
May Allah guide our efforts and grant us the wisdom to fulfill this trust with integrity and fairness. Thank you very much for listening.
Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh.
0 Comments